On Friday, the Ortega-Murillo and Alianza Cívica negotiators signed two agreements. The first secures the release of all political prisoners, and the second deals with rights and guarantees afforded to all Nicaraguan citizens, by virtue of the Nicaraguan Constitution.
The litmus test for the second agreement came on Saturday afternoon, after Unidad Nacional Azul y Blanco (UNAB) called for a “national sit in.”
The Ortega administration failed stupendously when riot police geared up against protesters at Metrocentro. The agreement didn’t even make it past the 24-hour mark before it was violated.
The police arrested seven people at Metrocentro, and three protesters were wounded after an armed man opened fire on the crowd.
2-3 pm – local time
Metrocentro is a privately-owned shopping mall in Managua. It has been the site of renewed protests since UNAB staged #AlaCalle, on March 16. These images show the start of the of the gathering.
Imágenes de la protesta en Metrocentro minutos antes que la Policía agrediera a los manifestantes. pic.twitter.com/eK958p3DaI
— Ivette Munguia (@Ivymunguia) March 30, 2019
These protesters climbed the fence
Que se rinda tu madre gritan todos los autoconvocados en metrocentro en la sentada nacional contra la dictadura Ortega-Murillo @laprensa @hoynoticias #SOSNicaragua pic.twitter.com/af88PtvJo1
— Oscar Navarrete (@navax1969) March 30, 2019
Protesters chanted anti-government slogans. Flor Ramírez (aka Doña Flor) can be seen on the left, wearing a blue and white huipil. She would be among the first to be arrested.
Varios autoconvocados gritan No es un Presidente, es un Delincuente! en la plaza de metrocentro en la gran sentada nacional @laprensa @hoynoticias pic.twitter.com/7omwwRIjZS
— Oscar Navarrete (@navax1969) March 30, 2019
Minutos antes que fuera apresada doña Flor Ramírez.
Fotografía: Antonio Ramírez/@obreradelatecla pic.twitter.com/BhVecJQ9fq
— Antonio Ramírez (@antonioramirezr) March 30, 2019
At approximately 2 pm, local time Trinchera de La Noticia posted these images, showing a large concentration of police officers outside Metrocentro. According to Trinchera, protesters were trapped inside.
Grupo de policias antimontines se encuentran en las afuera de #Metrocentro y mantienen a los manifestantes dentro de este centro comercial. Manifestantes quisieron salir a la calle y la unidad de antimontines lo impidieron.#SOSNicaragua #Nicaragua #Ultimahora #Ultimominuto pic.twitter.com/Bsdx55Z1JG
— Trinchera de la Noticia (@LaTrincheraNic) March 30, 2019
The police broke into the perimeter and proceeded to grab and drag protesters out. This happened some time between 2:30 and 3 pm.
Ni 24 horas duró el respeto de la dictadura a los acuerdos presentados ayer junto a la @AlianzaCivicaNi con el Nuncio y el enviado de @Almagro_OEA2015 Golpearon y secuestraron a gente q ejercía su derecho. Entre ellos mujeres mayores y periodistas. #SOSNICARAGUA pic.twitter.com/oTl9jjSzSu
— pxmolina (@pxmolina) March 30, 2019
The images and video from Managua show riot police officers ganging up on protesters. Flor Ramírez was forcefully removed from the premises.
Que clase de terror el de los Ortega Murillo: secuestraron a doña Flor por sentarse en la acera con su huipil y desplegaron la "zopilotera" contra jóvenes en Metrocentro. Ortega patea los acuerdos con la @AlianzaCivicaNi pic.twitter.com/B2U0Y2Dmft
— Dora María Téllez (@DoraMTellez) March 30, 2019
There are several videos showing Doña Flor’s arrest. She was among the first people to be dragged out of the Metrocentro premises.
Oficiales de la Policía arrastraron y se llevaron detenida a doña Flor Ramírez, la señora del hupil, por haber salido a la calle a protestar. @confidencial_ni pic.twitter.com/FdyPlW5LEO
— Ivette Munguia (@Ivymunguia) March 30, 2019
This is another view of Doña Flor’s forceful removal from Metrocentro. Two other unidentified protesters were also forced onto police vehicles.
#VIDEO Este es el momento del ataque policial a los manifestantes en @MetrocentroNic 🚨📱👇
📹 Cortesía pic.twitter.com/thayu1pYyj
— nicaraguainvestiga (@nicaraguainvest) March 30, 2019
Doña Flor Ramírez, la señora que en todas las protestas baila vestida con un huipil azul y blanco, también fue detenida por la Policía Orteguista, que nuevamente viola el derecho a la libre manifestación en #Nicaragua >> https://t.co/mYClJ47jFi #SOSNicaragua pic.twitter.com/ygE9cgrGWS
— LA PRENSA Nicaragua (@laprensa) March 30, 2019
The “arrest” of an unidentified protester, documented by La Prensa.
Esta foto es de hoy. Un día después de que el régimen orteguista se comprometiera supuestamente a respetar el derecho a la manifestación. Yo no les creo nada. Foto de @navax1969 para @laprensa pic.twitter.com/FLReGQnrsS
— Dora Luz Romero (@dromero2) March 30, 2019
The team from Accion 10 news filmed the police action against protesters. They were attacked too.
Por esta razón agredieron al equipo de Canal 10. Desnudó a nivel nacional la violación a los acuerdos prometidos por Ortega, dentro de ellos la libre movilización, libre expresión y uso de símbolos nacionales. pic.twitter.com/AGSUnXxPPF
— Houston Castillo (@HoustonTexasni) March 30, 2019
The police reported seven arrests. Everyone was released later.
Comunicado número 11 – 2019 de la Policía Nacional#Canal4Noticias pic.twitter.com/h3otfRNYWQ
— Canal 4 Nicaragua (@Canal4Ni) March 31, 2019
This young girl witnessed the police action. She asks “why are you repressing us?”
"¿Por qué nos reprimen?", se pregunta esta pequeña entre lágrimas, frente a los antimotines que llegaron a #Metrocentro para detener a los manifestantes. Los menores de edad también han sufrido estos largos 11 meses. En la lista oficial de asesinados hay 28 menores. #SOSNicaragua pic.twitter.com/vrqWmjedJ7
— Josué Garay (@_JosueGaray) March 30, 2019
In spite of police presence, protests continue at the Metrocentro parking lot. This group jumps to the chant, “if you don’t jump, you’re a toadie.”
Imposibilitados de manifestarse en la calle, los autoconvocados marchan por el parqueo del centro comercial Metrocentro mientras la Policía tiene rodeado el perímetro del lugar. @confidencial_ni pic.twitter.com/N3FLuvZvDX
— Ivette Munguia (@Ivymunguia) March 30, 2019
A pesar de la reprensión policial los autoconvocados permanecen en las instalaciones de metrocentro #SOSNicaragua @laprensa @hoynoticias pic.twitter.com/JUaqK06ItZ
— Oscar Navarrete (@navax1969) March 30, 2019
Protests also happened elsewhere in Managua. This video, from Barrio María Auxiliadora, shows police approaching a group of protesters. The police accuse them of public disorder. The protesters retort “what about the agreements?” One protester confronts the police, yelling “My brother was killed. Are you going to bring him back?”
Y mientras corría la sangre en Metrocentro (producidas por las balas asesinas disparadas por un paramilitar orteguista); en otro sector de Managua (barrio María Auxiliadora) el pueblo pudo realizar un pequeño piquete exprés de protesta contra el régimen en pista Juan Pablo II. pic.twitter.com/61vWN4H0Mt
— Israel González Espinoza (@israeldej94) March 30, 2019
Another angle of the same picket, before the police arrived. People are on the sidewalk. No one is obstructing traffic or acting violently.
Parada del Paraisito#SOSNicaragua pic.twitter.com/merNi2V6gi
— Jarot🇳🇮 (@JarotPayanS) March 30, 2019
The right to peaceful assembly and protest are guaranteed in the Nicaragua constitution, which yesterday’s agreement takes as a reference. The agreement reiterates the government’s obligation to respect for citizens’ rights.
#LoÚltimo | Acuerdo para fortalecer los derechos y garantías ciudadanas. Policía y Ejército a desarmar los paramilitares. Manifestaciones se deben permitir y se revisará la cancelación de personerias jurídicas. #SOSNicaragua pic.twitter.com/MFW9N2E6EL
— Wilmer Benavides Fonseca (@chepitillo1) March 30, 2019
Among other things, the agreement says that “The State guarantees that no one can be subjected to arbitrary detention or prison, nor be deprived of their freedom, except for reasons established by law”. The accord further acknowledges that “no prior permission is needed to exercise the right to peaceful assembly, as long as it does not impede free circulation of people and vehicles, and does not alter the normal coexistence among the population.”
In other words, this gathering, in Matagalpa, is legal, as it does not impede free circulation. It also doesn’t seem to be bothering anyone’s “normal coexistence.”
Matagalpa también se sumó a la sentada nacional. #SOSNicaragua
— Wilmer Benavides Fonseca (@chepitillo1) March 30, 2019
Nevertheless, riot police was at hand, across the street.
Policia se encuentra frente a Catedral de #Matagalpa mientras jovenes se encuentran manifestandose pacificamente.#SOSNicaragua #Nicaragua #Ultimahora #Ultimominuto #Urgente #SosMatagalpa pic.twitter.com/iQzaH5aE0D
— Trinchera de la Noticia (@LaTrincheraNic) March 30, 2019
In the document signed YESTERDAY, both parties “recognize” that the state is primarily responsible for carrying out the agreements. “The state, its branches, institutions and other organs commit themselves, as is their constitutional duty according to Article 6 of the Constitution, to implement this agreement in strict compliance with established constitutional principles.”
The state has failed to do so, again.
The Alianza Civica condemned the police attacks via Twitter. They have demanded the release of everyone who was detained illegally at Metrocentro. Their tweet ends by stating that “[Political] will is demonstrated through actions.”
Condenamos enérgicamente la flagrante violación a los derechos de las personas que se habían reunido pacíficamente en Metrocentro y exigimos la inmediata liberación de quienes fueron detenidos ilegalmente. La voluntad se demuestra con hechos.
— Alianza Cívica Nicaragua (@AlianzaCivicaNi) March 30, 2019
4 pm – local time
At approximately 4 pm, local time, a man opened fire against protesters. The crowd surrounded, disarmed, and beat him up. Local press reports he wounded at least three people.
Al menos cinco disparos se escucharon en el parqueo de Metrocentro, los manifestantes lanzan piedras y golpean a la persona que supuestamente hizo los disparos. @confidencial_ni pic.twitter.com/ZEIEvBjlrt
— Ivette Munguia (@Ivymunguia) March 30, 2019
Este es el sujeto que hirió a 3 autoconvocados hace unos momentos, en su bolsillo cargaba las municiones y el arma #SOSNicaragua @laprensa @hoynoticias pic.twitter.com/IbgLPydRrb
— Oscar Navarrete (@navax1969) March 30, 2019
The man was later identified as German Dávila Blanco. He was carrying his FSLN membership card. Dávila is a former military. Protesters took the ID from Dávila after subduing and beating him up.
#LoÚltimo Hombre identificado con carné del FSLN es señalado de disparar contra manifestantes en Metrocentro y 3 personas resultan heridas https://t.co/QHjlx4atru 👈 pic.twitter.com/uJjnXfc36C
— Maje (@majenicaragua) March 30, 2019
A press photographer for El Nuevo Diario took a picture at the moment of the attack. The picture shows a man in a blue stripped shirt, presumably Dávila, with his back turned to the photographer.
Fotógrafo de El Nuevo Diario captó el momento en que militante sandinista disparó contra manifestantes en Metrocentro dejando varias personas heridas
Más información aquí
👇👇https://t.co/h3dwOuxmTH pic.twitter.com/RfRAUxF8nb— El Nuevo Diario (@elnuevodiario) March 31, 2019
A similar shirt can be seen on Dávila in this image, taken after he was subdued by the crowd.
Policía acomoda agresión en versión oficial https://t.co/gizQ7n8H1z
— Obrera de la Tecla (@obreradelatecla) March 31, 2019
Other images have emerged. This one shows a man in a blue stripped shirt, holding a gun.
Los medios oficiales defienden a este sujeto q disparó a quemarropa contra un grupo de nicaragüense que protestaban contra el dictador. pic.twitter.com/UdVSiYADIi
— Gerall Chávez N. (@GerallChavez) March 31, 2019
There is also video, from a news crew that was filming the rally. The video shows the moment when a man, presumably Dávila, was tackled and wrestled to the ground.
Oportuna acción de este joven, abalanzándose sobre paramilitar, Germán Dávila, evitó q hiriera a + personas. La PO presenta a este pistolero como un anciano de 70 años que fue atacado sin razón. La imagen muestra al sujeto cuando se disponía a seguir disparando a manifestantes. pic.twitter.com/sAkfZY8mV3
— Miguel Mendoza (@Mmendoza1970) March 31, 2019
There is also video of the police, at the time of the gun fire. They don’t move.
Momento en que se escucharon los disparos que realizó Germán Dávila, el ex retirado del EPS e infiltrado del gobierno en la manifestación de hoy en Metrocentro.
Video: León-Vandálico#SOSNicaragua #Nicaragua #Nicaragüense pic.twitter.com/5P4f96ekfA— Trinchera de la Noticia (@LaTrincheraNic) March 31, 2019
As a result of the attack, there were several people wounded. They were cared for on site, before transport to local hospitals.
Uno de los heridos que recibió un disparo en el tobillo cuando un paramilitar infiltró la protesta y disparó a los manifestantes #SOSNicaragua @laprensa @hoynoticias pic.twitter.com/tKVBP9UaeQ
— Oscar Navarrete (@navax1969) March 30, 2019
Una persona de civil disparó contra los manifestantes azul y blanco y hay varios heridos @laprensa pic.twitter.com/SLM1Rynngj
— Roy Moncada (@moncadaroy) March 30, 2019
Yesterday’s agreement included a government commitment to “disarm anyone carrying weapons without authorization.”
The police have yet to arrest him.
The Alianza Civica issued a statement saying that the “Ortega-Murillo regime have once again put at risk the negotiations and the search for peaceful and constitutional solutions. The regime puts citizens in danger, by failing to comply with its obligation to recognize and protect the rights of Nicaraguans.”
#AlianzaInforma | “Condenamos nuevamente la represión al pueblo y exigimos el cumplimiento de los acuerdos” pic.twitter.com/NpGhIhAtgq
— Alianza Cívica Nicaragua (@AlianzaCivicaNi) March 30, 2019
6 pm
Police Commissioner Jaime Vanegas read the official police version of the attack at Metrocentro. According to the police, the protesters caused the violence.
The police statement characterized protesters as “violent groups” who have been “invading private property over the past three weekends.” The police accused these “violent groups” of “altering public order, disturbing commerce and normal coexistence, and attacking people.”
As for the attack at Metrocentro, the police state that it was protesters who accosted and “attacked women and children.” Later, they “surrounded seventy-year-old German Felix Davila and attacked, both verbally and and physically.”
Comunicado de Prensa de la Policia Nacional de #Nicaragua 🇳🇮 pic.twitter.com/dsSYWrmdEV
— Canal 2 (@Canal2Nicaragua) March 30, 2019
Dávila’s FSLN party membership card includes his national ID number. The year of birth is the number immediately preceding the three zeroes. In Dávila’s case, that number is 62, which means that he is 57 years old, not 70, as the police states. The ID was taken from Dávila by the group that subdued him.
#LoÚltimo Hombre identificado con carné del FSLN es señalado de disparar contra manifestantes en Metrocentro y 3 personas resultan heridas https://t.co/QHjlx4atru 👈 pic.twitter.com/uJjnXfc36C
— Maje (@majenicaragua) March 30, 2019
As for the attack on Dávila, the police uses video of it to argue it was unprovoked. According to the police, the gunshots “occurred as the aggression [upon Dávila] was taking place.”
In other words, Dávila could not have fired the shots that injured at least three people, since he was being “lynched” at the time.
Dávila was taken to the hospital. His condition was described as “delicate.”
The police promises to investigate the matter. However, it is clear that the official version is already set.
The OrMu propaganda machine is framing the attack on Dávila not as self-defense, but as an aggression carried out by “terrorist groups”, “right-wing fascists”, and “coup mongers.” Barricada describes the situation as caused by “terrorist groups,” Canal 4 describes the same groups as “small-sized, right-wing, fascist coup-mongers,” and Canal 8 opts for “”right-wing fascists.”
#UltimaHora | La tarde de este sábado grupos terroristas intimidaron y amenazaron la tranquilidad y la paz de las familias que visitaron un centro comercial capitalino.
Lea el comunicado íntegro https://t.co/UpFSdshpPb
— Barricada (@Barricada79) March 30, 2019
#ENVIVO POR CANAL 4
Grupos reducidos de la derecha fascista y golpista agredieron a ciudadanos en Metrocentro#NoPudieronNiPodrán https://t.co/7G9zGkQAIw— Canal 4 Nicaragua (@Canal4Ni) March 30, 2019
#AHORA #Nicaragua| Policía Nacional brinda conferencia de prensa sobre los actos violentos que han hecho la derecha fascista este sábado.#NicaraguaQuierePaz pic.twitter.com/Jn4xEk3anI
— TN8 Nicaragua (@canaltn8) March 30, 2019
No OrMu media outlets has reported on the violent police crackdown at Metrocentro or on the breach of the accords.